top of page
  • Carmel Homes

From Charming to Chaotic: Melbourne's Housing Crisis Explained

Updated: May 30

Written by Adib Adely, Director of Carmel Homes

Melbourne's once-charming dream of home ownership is fading for many residents. The city is grappling with a complex housing crisis, fueled by a tangled web of factors. From rigid height restrictions hindering development to a lack of diversity in housing options, the path to finding a suitable and affordable place to live has become increasingly challenging. This article dives into the intricate web of issues contributing to Melbourne's housing woes, exploring how everything from inflexible regulations to community concerns is playing a role in this growing problem.

Melbourne's Housing Crisis Explained

Melbourne's Housing Crisis: Stuck Between McMansions and Skyscraper

The current one-size-fits-all approach to development approvals, where zoning restricts options to either sprawling single-family homes or high-rise apartment blocks, is fueling the rise of housing prices in Melbourne. This lack of diversity fails to meet the varying needs and budgets of potential residents. By only allowing for these extremes, the market is missing the crucial middle ground: medium-density developments like townhouses, units and low-rise apartments. These options offer a more affordable and space-efficient alternative for many buyers, particularly young families or those seeking a more urban lifestyle. Without this diversity, demand continues to outpace supply, particularly for those seeking more affordable options, pushing housing prices ever higher.

Melbourne's Housing Fix: One Block, Two Homes, Clear Rules

Current regulations in Melbourne streamline building approvals for single homes, but building two dwellings on a single property becomes a complex process. Wouldn't it be great if a similar set of clear guidelines existed for dual occupancies? Imagine a system that simplifies building two homes on suitable plots, effectively doubling the supply of desirable housing options. This could be a game-changer in tackling the housing crisis.

Council Gridlock: Red Tape Choking Housing Supply

Slow council approval times for medium-density housing developments create a domino effect of problems. Delays lead to increased costs for developers, which get passed on to buyers in the form of higher prices. The uncertainty and extended timelines also discourage developers from taking on these projects in the first place, ultimately restricting the supply of much-needed units and townhouses. This lack of supply fuels housing shortages and discourages innovation in sustainable or creative medium-density housing design.

9-Meter Menace: Victoria's Home Setback Law Stifling Development, Pushing Up Prices

Victoria's 9m home setback law, while intended to preserve aesthetics and amenity, can hinder development in several ways. Firstly, it reduces the usable land area on a property, potentially making it difficult to build affordable or sustainable homes. This can lead to urban sprawl as development pushes further out to meet housing needs. Secondly, the law limits design flexibility, potentially forcing homes into cookie-cutter styles that don't respond well to the specific features of a block. Finally, it can inflate land prices as the usable area shrinks, making housing even less accessible.

While preserving amenity is important, a more nuanced approach to setbacks that considers factors like lot size and architectural design could be more beneficial for sustainable and creative development.

Sky's the Limit? Not in Melbourne

Melbourne's uniform 9-meter height restriction for homes suffocates development and fuels rising house prices. It limits options for higher-density housing in suitable areas, forcing sprawl and failing to meet demand. This inflexibility hinders innovation and discourages creative solutions. In contrast, a range of heights within a zone would unlock opportunities. It allows for diverse housing options catering to different needs, promotes smarter use of space with potential for mixed-use developments, and fosters sustainable communities. This flexibility is key to a healthier housing market in Melbourne.

Two-Level Tyranny: Victorian Law Crushing Home Dreams

Relatively recent laws restricting home builds to two levels in most Victorian areas throws a wrench into development plans. This one-size-fits-all approach hinders creativity and innovation. While height restrictions are important for maintaining a neighbourhood's character, a blanket two-level rule disregards situations where a three-level structure could fit comfortably within existing height limitations. This inflexibility discourages developers from exploring efficient use of space, potentially leading to urban sprawl as more land is needed for single-level builds. Ultimately, such restrictions may stifle the creation of much-needed high-density housing options within established suburbs.

Not In My Backyard? Melbourne Needs Open Dialogue, Not NIMBY Noise

Community concerns can be a major obstacle for development in Melbourne. Residents often fear new projects will disrupt their existing way of life, leading to increased traffic, noise, and strain on amenities. Feeling uninformed or unheard during the planning process can further escalate opposition. Additionally, negative perceptions about the type of development planned can fuel anxieties about property values and safety.

However, not all residents resist change. Some see development as an opportunity for improvements like better infrastructure or revitalization of an area. Open communication is key. When developers, councils, and residents engage in a transparent dialogue, they can address concerns and find solutions that benefit both the community and the project.

Community opposition, while a hurdle, can also be a chance for a more collaborative and thoughtful approach to urban planning in Melbourne. By fostering open communication and addressing genuine concerns, development projects can gain wider acceptance and contribute positively to the city's evolution.

The Future can be Bright

The path forward for Melbourne's housing crisis requires a multi-pronged approach. Rethinking outdated height restrictions and zoning laws to allow for a wider range of housing options, from townhouses to low-rise apartments, is crucial. Fostering open communication between developers, councils, and residents can ensure new projects address genuine concerns while contributing positively to the city's evolution. Ultimately, Melbourne needs a housing market that caters to a diverse range of needs and budgets, not just sprawling mansions or towering apartment blocks. By embracing innovative solutions and fostering a collaborative spirit, Melbourne can unlock its true housing potential and ensure a brighter future for its residents.



Contact Us for a free consultation

Thanks for submitting!



Dozens of inspirational articles and tips on building and designing your home.

Sign up for our weekly tips and articles

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page