top of page
  • Carmel Homes

Is a Knock Down Rebuild Worth It?

Thinking about completely transforming your living space? A knock down rebuild might be an option you're considering. But before you make the decision, it's so important to weigh the pros and cons to see if it aligns with your needs and budget.

Knockdown rebuild

Pros of Knock Down Rebuilds

Designing Your Dream Home

A knockdown and rebuild allows you to completely customize your living space. Unlike renovations that work around the existing structure, a custom home builder offers a blank canvas. Here are some aspects you can tailor to your preferences:

  • Layout: Imagine an open floor plan for entertaining or separate living areas for privacy. You can design the flow of your home to perfectly suit your lifestyle.

  • Features: Do you crave a walk-in closet or a home theater? Include all the features you've always dreamed of having in your new modern or French Provincial home.

  • Finishes: From flooring and countertops to lighting fixtures and paint colors, every detail can be chosen to reflect your unique style and taste.

Living with Modern Conveniences

New homes typically incorporate the latest advancements in technology and building practices:

  • Smart home technology: Imagine controlling lights, thermostats, or even appliances with your voice or smartphone.

  • Energy-saving features: Modern homes often utilize energy-efficient appliances, insulation, and heating/cooling systems, potentially lowering your utility bills.

  • Sustainable materials: Eco-friendly landscape design and building materials can be incorporated to reduce your environmental impact.

Potential Increase in Property Value

Generally, a well-designed new home on an existing block of land can be a wise investment. Here's how a design and build rebuild might increase your property value:

  • Increased desirability: A modern, well-maintained French Provincial home is often more attractive to potential buyers compared to an old property.

  • Improved functionality: A well-designed layout that meets current living trends can make your home more appealing.

  • Greater living space: If your rebuild adds square footage, it can significantly increase the value of your property.

  • Potential for Energy Savings

Modern building techniques and materials can lead to a more energy-efficient home:

  • Advanced insulation: Proper insulation can significantly reduce heating and cooling costs.

  • High-performance windows: Modern windows can let in natural light while minimizing heat transfer.

  • Energy-efficient appliances: Look for appliances with high Energy Star ratings to save on electricity and water usage. By prioritizing energy efficiency during the construction phase, you can potentially enjoy a more comfortable and sustainable living space while saving money on utility bills in the long run.

Cons of Knock Down Rebuilds

Significant Investment

Knockdown and rebuild projects require a substantial amount of upfront capital. Here's a breakdown of some of the costs to consider:

  • Demolition: The process of tearing down your existing structure incurs costs.

  • Building costs: The materials and labor involved in building your new custom home will be a major expense.

  • Permits and fees: Obtaining necessary permits and approvals from local authorities can add to the overall cost.

  • Temporary accommodation: You'll likely need to find a place to live while construction takes place.

While the initial cost is high, it's important to consider the potential long-term benefits like a return on investment when you eventually sell the property. A well-built and well-designed French Provincial home can potentially increase in value over time.

Time Commitment

Knock down and rebuild projects are complex and can take a year or more to complete. Here's what to expect regarding the timeline:

  • Planning stages: Obtaining permits, finalizing design and build plans, and securing financing all take time.

  • Construction: The actual building process itself can be lengthy depending on the size and complexity of the project.

Challenges and Permits

The legal and regulatory aspects of a knock down and rebuild can be complex. Here are some hurdles you might encounter:

  • Council restrictions: Local zoning regulations may limit the size, style, or placement of your new modern home.

  • Permits: Obtaining the necessary building permits from local authorities can involve paperwork and approvals.

Working with experienced custom home builders familiar with local regulations can help you navigate these challenges and ensure your project stays on track.

Disruption to Your Life

Living arrangements will need to be addressed while construction is underway. Here's what to consider:

  • Temporary accommodation: You'll likely need to find a place to live during the construction phase, which can be disruptive to your routine.

  • Moving: The process of relocating can be stressful, especially if you have a family or pets.

Careful planning and communication with your design and build team can help minimize disruptions and make the temporary move as smooth as possible though

Knock Down Rebuild vs. Renovation

Choosing between a knock down and rebuild and a renovation truly just depends on your needs and goals for your home. So here's a breakdown of them to help you decide:

  • Renovation

  • Good for: Updating existing features, improving functionality, addressing minor structural issues.

  • Benefits: Often less expensive than a rebuild, less disruptive to your life, may preserve the character of an older home.

  • Drawbacks: May not address major structural problems, limited design flexibility compared to a rebuild.

  • Knock Down Rebuild

  • Good for: Creating a completely new design, addressing major structural issues, maximizing space and functionality.

  • Benefits: Complete design control, opportunity to incorporate modern features and technologies, potential to increase property value.

  • Drawbacks: Significant investment of time and money, disruptive to your living situation, may require permits and approval processes.

  • Choosing the right option - the factors to consider;

    • The condition of your existing home: If your home has a solid foundation and good bones, a renovation might be sufficient.

    • Your design vision: If you crave a completely new layout or modern features, a custom home builder and design and build may be the better option.

    • Budget and timeline: Renovations are generally less expensive and time-consuming than knock down and rebuild projects.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific circumstances. Consulting with a qualified custom home builder or architect can help you weigh the pros and cons and determine the best course of action for your dream French Provincial home or modern home design.

Other Options

Extending Your Existing Home

  • An extension can be a good middle ground between a renovation and a complete knock down rebuild. Here's what to consider:

  • Pros: Adds extra space without the disruption of a full rebuild, potentially increases property value.

  • Cons: May not address underlying structural issues, may have limitations depending on the existing home's layout.

  • Examples of home extensions:

  • Adding a new bedroom or bathroom

  • Expanding the kitchen or living area

  • Creating a home office or sunroom

Buying a New House

Depending on your needs and budget, buying a new house might be a simpler solution altogether. Here's a breakdown of this option:

  • Pros: Potentially less hassle than a major renovation or rebuild, find a house that already meets your needs, move into a new neighborhood.

  • Cons: Less customization compared to a rebuild, may cost more than renovating your existing home.

  • Before you decide:

  • Consider your priorities: How important is customizing your space compared to finding a move-in ready option?

  • Make a list of your needs and wants: What features are essential in your new home?

  • Factor in additional costs: Closing costs, moving expenses, potential property taxes in a new neighborhood.

Ultimately, the best choice for you depends on your individual circumstances. Researching your options and talking to professionals can help you find the solution that best suits your needs.

The Final Decision

Deciding if a knock down rebuild is worth it entirely depends on your individual circumstances. Weigh the pros and cons carefully, consider your budget and timeline, and explore other options before making a decision. While a knock down rebuild can be a complex and costly undertaking, it also offers the opportunity to create your dream home from the ground up. By carefully planning and executing your project with the help of a qualified custom home builder and design and build team, you can turn your vision into reality and enjoy the benefits of a beautiful and functional new home for years to come. Interested? Contact Carmel Homes for a consultation to see if a knock down rebuild is the right option for you!



Contact Us for a free consultation

Thanks for submitting!



Dozens of inspirational articles and tips on building and designing your home.

Sign up for our weekly tips and articles

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page